Saleor is a modern, open-source e-commerce platform based on GraphQL that offers developers a flexible and customisable solution for online sales. Unlike traditional shop systems, which are often monolithic and less customisable, Saleor enables a modular architecture that allows companies to design their e-commerce solutions according to their specific needs. This flexibility is particularly advantageous for companies that operate in a dynamic market environment and need to react quickly to changes.
Traditional shop systems, on the other hand, are often designed as complete solutions that offer a variety of functions in a single package. These systems are often less flexible and can be limited in their customisability. Examples of such systems are Magento, WooCommerce or Shopify.
While they offer a wide range of functions, they may be inadequate for companies that have specific requirements or operate in niche markets. The choice between Saleor and traditional shop systems therefore depends heavily on a company's individual needs and goals.
Key Takeaways
- Saleor is a modern, flexible and open source shop system, whereas traditional shop systems are often based on older technologies.
- Saleor offers a high level of functionality and adaptability thanks to its modular architecture, whereas traditional shop systems are often less flexible.
- The cost of implementing Saleor can be higher, but the long-term operating costs are often lower compared to traditional shop systems.
- Saleor offers a better user experience for customers and retailers through its modern user interface and user-friendly features.
- In terms of security and data protection, Saleor often offers better measures and guidelines compared to traditional shop systems.
Functionality and customisability: How do Saleor and traditional shop systems differ in terms of their functionality and customisability?
The functionality of Saleor is strongly focussed on the needs of modern e-commerce applications. By using GraphQL, developers can specifically query only the data they need, which increases the efficiency of the application. This API-first architecture enables companies to develop and optimise their front-end and back-end systems independently of each other.
In addition, Saleor offers a variety of integrations with third-party services, which further increases customisability. Companies can add specific functions or modify existing functions to meet their individual requirements. In contrast, traditional shop systems often offer fixed functionality that is not always easily customisable.
While many of these systems offer a wide range of plugins and extensions, the integration of new functions can often be time-consuming and costly. Additionally, many of these systems are not designed for an API-first architecture, which means that changes to the backend often require adjustments to the frontend as well. This can lead to increased complexity and limit a company's agility, especially when it comes to reacting quickly to market changes.
Costs and implementation: What costs are associated with the use of Saleor and traditional shop systems and how complex is their implementation?
The cost of implementing Saleor can vary, depending on a company's specific requirements and the level of customisation desired. As Saleor is an open source platform, there are no licence fees, making it a cost-effective option for companies that have the technical resources to host and customise the platform themselves. However, companies usually need to invest in developers to configure and implement the platform according to their needs.
This can result in high initial costs, but these can be offset by the long-term flexibility and adaptability of the platform. Traditional shop systems, on the other hand, often have higher initial costs due to licence fees and implementation costs. Many of these systems also require regular maintenance fees or subscriptions, which can increase the overall cost over time.
Implementation can also be time-consuming, especially if the system requires extensive customisation or if the company needs to migrate existing data. In many cases, companies are forced to call in external consultants or agencies to ensure that the system is set up correctly, which incurs additional costs.
User-friendliness and customer experience: Which system offers a better user experience for customers and retailers?
The user experience is a decisive factor for the success of an e-commerce system. With its modern architecture and API-first approach, Saleor offers a high degree of flexibility when designing the front end. Developers can create customised user interfaces that are tailored to the specific needs of their target group.
This enables companies to create a unique shopping experience that stands out from the competition. In addition, Saleor supports multiple payment methods and shipping options, allowing customers a seamless checkout experience. While traditional shop systems often offer a user-friendly interface "out of the box", this standardisation can also have limitations.
Many of these systems are designed to appeal to a broad target group, which means that they may not take into account all the specific needs of a company or its customers. Customisations to the user interface can be complicated and often require deeper technical knowledge or additional plugins. This can result in a less intuitive shopping experience that cannot be optimised to meet customer expectations.
Security and data protection: Which system offers better security measures and data protection guidelines?
Security is a key concern in the e-commerce sector, as online retailers have to deal with sensitive customer data. Saleor places great emphasis on security and offers various integrated security functions such as HTTPS encryption and protection against cross-site scripting (XSS) and cross-site request forgery (CSRF). As it is an open source platform, users benefit from an active community that regularly provides security updates and identifies potential vulnerabilities.
Companies also have the option of implementing and customising their own security measures. Traditional shop systems also have security measures implemented; however, these can vary depending on the provider. Some systems offer comprehensive security features as part of their service, while others may charge additional fees for advanced security options.
A common problem with traditional systems is the dependence on third-party services for certain security functions, which harbours potential risks. In addition, security updates can be provided more slowly in monolithic systems, which makes companies more vulnerable to attacks.
Scalability and growth: Which system is better suited to keep pace with a company's growth and be scalable?
Scalability through modular architecture
Scalability is a crucial factor for companies that want to grow. Saleor was developed with scalability in mind and allows companies to customise their infrastructure as needed. Saleor's modular architecture means that organisations can add new features or extend existing functionality without having to redesign the entire system.
Advantages for companies in dynamic markets
This is particularly advantageous for companies in fast-moving markets or those with seasonal fluctuations in sales volumes. In contrast, traditional shop systems can be limited in their scalability. Many of these systems are not designed to handle large amounts of data or high user numbers efficiently.
Performance problems with traditional shop systems
When a company grows and adds more products or customers, this can lead to performance problems. In some cases, companies have to resort to more expensive hosting solutions or additional hardware to meet the requirements. This can not only be costly, but also time-consuming to implement.
Support and maintenance: How do the support and maintenance services of Saleor and traditional shop systems differ?
Support is another important aspect when choosing an e-commerce system. Saleor offers an active community and extensive documentation for developers. This enables users to quickly find solutions to common problems or receive support from other developers.
For companies that require professional support, there are also commercial support offerings from third-party providers or directly from the developers of Saleor. Traditional shop systems often offer a formal support service, which can vary depending on the provider. Some systems offer 24/7 support, while others are only available during certain business hours.
The quality of support can also vary; some providers have an excellent reputation for fast and effective service, while others may be slower to respond or offer less helpful solutions. In addition, support costs can rise quickly with traditional systems, especially if organisations require frequent assistance.
Conclusion: Which system is best suited to which company's needs?
The choice between Saleor and traditional shop systems depends heavily on a company's specific needs. Saleor is particularly suitable for companies that require flexibility and adaptability and have the technical resources to develop a customised solution. It is ideal for start-ups or growing companies in dynamic markets.
Traditional shop systems, on the other hand, can be beneficial for smaller companies or those with less complex requirements, as they often offer a user-friendly interface and can be implemented quickly. Ultimately, companies should consider their long-term goals as well as their technical capabilities to choose the right e-commerce system.
English (UK) 
Deutsch 
Nederlands 
Türkçe 
Ελληνικά 
Français de Belgique 
Español 
English